Gravity Factor Matrix for Adults (v3.0, 2013)
Which matrix does my force use?
This information was supplied by the NPCC on 26/10/2026. Users should check with their force.
1.0 Introduction
1.1 A simple caution was renamed to distinguish it from a conditional caution. It is a non-statutory disposal for adult offenders and may be used for disposing of offences when specified public interest and eligibility criteria are met. A Gravity Factor Matrix has been developed by the Association of Chief Police Officers (ACPO) to assist in making cautioning / charging decisions for adults. For further information refer to the Ministry of Justice Guidance on Simple Cautions. This document is available on the Ministry of Justice web site or via a link through APP post May 2013.
1.2 This matrix has been updated by the ACPO Out of Court Disposals portfolio to take into account the changes in out of court disposals introduced by the Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Act 2012 (LASPO) and revised caution guidance from the MOJ.
1.3 The key factors which will be relevant in deciding whether to charge, caution or conditionally caution an offender for an offence are:
(a) Do they admit the offence?
(b) The seriousness of the offence
(c) The previous offending history of the offender and
(d) Does the disposal adequately address, support and reduce the risk of reoffending?
(e) Where the Full Code Test is met, would the public interest be properly served by issuing a simple or Conditional Caution
(f) Views of the victim
1.4 The LASPO Act removes the need for the police to refer a Conditional Caution to the CPS for a decision for all summary only and either way offences exception in the case of a hate crime or domestic violence offence. Referral is still required, however for Indictable only offences. Please refer to the DPP’S Guidance on Adult Conditional Cautions 2013. This brings the position on Conditional Cautions in line with the position on simple cautions. Please refer to the MOJ guidance ‘Simple Cautions for adults’ for more information.
1.5 The tables below classify most common offences on a scale of 1 (low gravity) up to 4 (high gravity) based on the seriousness of the individual offence. The classifications in the tables are designed to assist in decision-making, but they cannot be regarded as a definitive guide, and must be considered alongside all the other issues outlined below. Factors which can make an offence more serious are shown as aggravating (+) while mitigating factors, making an offence less serious, are shown as (-). Some factors apply to all offences, including excluded offences in exceptional circumstances, and are listed as ‘General Factors’ while others are only applicable to specific offences and are listed as ‘Offence Specific Gravity Factors’.
*CPS link added on Page 9 for Assaults on Emergency Workers in July 2025. Matrix renamed v3.0
1.6 It is most important that the appropriate offence is determined according to the evidence, and that this is done before any consideration of the gravity factors. Equally, if having applied all the criteria, the police decision maker is considering a simple caution or conditional caution; care must be taken to ensure the offender stands reported or bailed for the appropriate offence and that there is no up-grading or down-grading simply to circumvent the criteria.
1.7 Having decided the appropriate offence, the gravity score can only be up-graded or down-graded by one point irrespective of the number of factors present. However, the mere presence of a (+) or (-) factor does not always mean an offence gravity score will be changed. It signifies a specific issue that must be considered by a decision maker, together with all the other matters and, if significant, can change the decision that would otherwise have been made. As a result it could be the deciding factor for a particular decision or have no bearing on the decision. The presence of both aggravating and mitigating factors may balance each other and result in no change to the original gravity score. It is important for decision makers to ensure that both the ‘offence specific gravity factors’ and the ‘general factors for all offences’ are considered for each offence for which a decision is made. This will ensure that the seriousness of the offence, the particular circumstances of it, and the offender’s current and previous behaviour are all considered. In every case the consideration given to aggravating and mitigating factors must be noted within the decision recorded.
2.0 Offences Not Shown in the Matrix
It is not possible to include all offences within this document. Any offences that are not shown should be dealt with in accordance with the general principles of this document.
.
3.0 Victims
It is important to consider the impact of the offence on the victim. Wherever possible, the victim should be contacted before a decision is made, to establish their view about the offence, the nature and extent of any harm or loss and its significance relative to the victim’s circumstances. The victim’s view about the offence may have a bearing on how serious the offence is judged to be but cannot be regarded as conclusive.
4.0 Hate Crimes
4.1 Hate crime involves any criminal offence which is perceived, by the victim or any other person, to be motivated by hostility or prejudice based on a personal characteristic. The definition covers five main strands, in particular - disability, gender-identity, race, religion or faith and sexual orientation.
4.2 Legislation has been in place for a number of years to protect victims from such hate crimes, including offences for those who intend to stir up racial hatred, and those who commit racially and religiously aggravated offences or engage in racist chanting at football matches. New criminal offences have also been introduced in recent years to reflect the seriousness of hate crime, including enhanced sentencing.
4.3 The offences are not included specifically in the matrix because the process of determining the gravity of the offence itself requires that where the victim’s race, religion, sexual orientation, disability or gender identity is a motivation, consideration must be given to raising the gravity score of the offence. For example, an offence of racially aggravated ABH (Section 47 OAP Act 1861), ABH attracts a gravity score of 3 in the matrix. Where the offence is racially aggravated ABH consideration must be given raising this to 4.
5.0 Knives and Offensive Weapons
5.1 It is recommended that forces follow the current ACPO guidance on Knife Crime. This guidance states that;
• For 18 years old and over there is a general expectation to charge any person for an offence involving knives, if there is sufficient evidence to do so. The factors that will support the decision to charge for all knife-crime offences are:
• Weapon used or violence threatened during commission of offence
• The offence, though minor, is prevalent in the local area – as identified in the local crime audit, specified in the youth justice plan or specifically agreed with CPS to warrant more serious response.
6.0 Values of Property
6.1 Some of the criteria include a consideration of monetary value relevant to offences. Flexibility should be demonstrated by police decision makers in comparing these values to those recorded against the relevant incident. Estimates of the value of property and of damage are often unreliable and tend to be subjective.
7.0 Traffic Related Offences
7.1 Traffic offences have their own set of aggravating and mitigating factors and therefore officers should take care to use this in the relevant cases. Officers should be aware that if a Caution is used there is no mechanism for endorsing driving licences; this should be taken into consideration when reaching a decision.
8.0 Previous Offending History
8.1 It is important to consider previous offending history in the decision making process, particularly the effectiveness of a previous out of court disposal in preventing reoffending. Officers should be aware of falling into the trap of repeat cautioning, the out of court disposal needs to be effective and where a court appearance is necessary the case should be charged. The MoJ guidance “Simple Cautions for Adult Offenders” and the “Code of Practice for Adult Conditional Cautions” provides detailed guidance on considering these disposals for those with a previous criminal history.
9.0 Using the ACPO gravity factors
9.1 The following pages show various tables that can be applied to the gravity factor system; the first page deals with offences that would usually be excluded from the options of caution or conditional caution, though in exceptional circumstances the general factors may be so significant that they could influence a reduction in gravity; the second and third pages list a number of general factors that might aggravate or mitigate the commission of any type of offence, including excluded offences in exceptional circumstances; and the remaining pages show lists of offences together with their standard gravity scores and those offence specific gravity factors that are considered appropriate to aggravate or mitigate each type of offence, according to the particular circumstances surrounding it. However, it should be remembered throughout the process that each case must be considered on its own merits and the decision making process should be recorded in full.
10.0.
10.0. The Director's Guidance on Charging 2011 is issued under the provisions of S37A of PACE 1984 and sets out the working arrangements for the joint working of police and prosecutors during the investigation and prosecution of criminal cases.
This Guidance sets out the responsibility for police and CPS Charging decisions as outlined below.
11.0 Police Charging Decisions
11.1 The police may charge any Summary only offence (including criminal damage where the value of the loss or damage is less than £5000) irrespective of plea and any either way offence anticipated as a guilty plea and suitable for sentence in a magistrates' court, provided it is not:
• a case requiring the consent to prosecute of the DPP or Law Officer;
• a case involving a death;
• connected with terrorist activity or official secrets;
• classified as Hate Crime or Domestic Violence under CPS Policies;
• an offence of Violent Disorder or Affray;
• causing Grievous Bodily Harm or Wounding, or Actual Bodily Harm;
• a Sexual Offences Act offence committed by or upon a person under 18;
• an offence under the Licensing Act 2003
12.0 CPS Charging Decisions
12.1 Prosecutors will make charging decisions in all Indictable only cases, any either way offence not suitable for sentence in a magistrates' court or not anticipated as a guilty plea, and the offences specified in the proviso above.
12.2 In a case where multiple offences under consideration for charging by the police includes any offence which must be referred to a prosecutor under this Guidance, then all offences in the case will be referred to a prosecutor to consider which should be charged.
12.3 Diversion from CPS:
12.4 The police may still take the decision to issue a simple caution or conditionally caution in all summary and either way offence without reference to the CPS where the police consider that the offender is eligible for such an out of court disposal. Hate crime and DV offences are excluded from the Conditional Cautioning scheme.
12.5 Additional guidance applies when considering a simple or conditional in certain either way cases. Officers should have regard to the Simple Caution guidance and DPP guidance on conditional cautions
12.5 The decision to issue a simple Caution or Conditional Caution in an indictable only offence must be referred to the CPS.
15.0 The Final Gravity Score
15.1 The presumptions applicable to the final gravity score reached, when all the relevant factors have been applied to the circumstances of a particular offence, are listed in the table below. This must be used in conjunction with the legislation in relation to the offender’s qualification for caution, conditional caution or charge.
15.2 Officers should remember that it will sometimes be necessary to consult agencies or departments such as the Crown Prosecution Service, Sex Crimes Department, Firearms Department, Licensing Officers, etc., before a final decision is made even if all the evidence is available.
15.3 This table relates to disposal/outcome decisions made by the custody officer for the offences shown and relates to action that should be taken once the final score is deduced.
*Note that where a conditional caution is being considered for a Foreign National Offenders the DPP Guidance should be referred to in terms of the seriousness of the offence for which a Conditional Caution may be offered.
| Final Score | Action |
|---|---|
| 4 | Always charge (or conditional caution – may need CPS decision if IO and exceptional circumstances). |
| 3 | Normally charge but a 'simple' caution (or conditional caution – may need CPS decision if IO and exceptional circumstances) may be appropriate if first offence. PND may be appropriate. |
| 2 | Normally 'simple' caution for a first offence but a charge (or conditional caution – may need CPS decision if IO and exceptional circumstances) may be appropriate if previous convictions or appropriate to circumstances. PND may be appropriate. |
| 1 | Always the minimum response applicable to the individual offender, i.e. NFA, 'simple' caution, PND, Community Resolution (or, exceptionally, charge). |
GENERAL FACTORS FOR ALL OFFENCES EXCEPT FOR TRAFFIC OFFENCES
- Conviction is likely to result in significant sentence.
- Weapon used or violence threatened during commission of offence.
- Offence against public servant (e.g. police, nurse, council employee, etc.).
- Offender abused a position of trust – e.g. banker, baby-sitter, shop assistant.
- Offender was ringleader/organiser.
- Evidence of premeditation.
- Offender was part of an organised team or offence was committed by a group.
- Victim was vulnerable, deliberately put in considerable fear or suffered personal attack, damage, disturbance, or domestic violence.
- Offence motivated by discrimination against victim's racial or ethnic origin, religious beliefs, gender, political views or sexual preference.
- There are grounds for believing the offence is likely to be repeated or continued – e.g. by a history of recurring conduct.
- Evidence of exploitation.
- The offence, though minor, is prevalent in the local area – as identified in the local crime audit, specified in the youth justice plan or specifically agreed with CPS to warrant more serious response.
- Conviction is likely to result in unusually small or nominal penalty.
- Prosecution is likely to have detrimental effect on victim's physical or mental health.
- Offender supplied information which reduced risk, loss or harm to others.
- Offender was influenced by others more criminally sophisticated.
- Genuine mistake or misunderstanding.
- Vulnerability of the offender.
- Provocation from victim or victim's group and offender reacted impulsively.
- The offence is minor and offender has put right harm or loss caused; has expressed regret; offered reparation or compensation.
- Offender is or was at time of offence suffering from significant mental or physical ill-health and offence is not likely to be repeated.
- The offence is so old that the relevance of any response is minimised, i.e. there has been a long delay between the offence occurring and the point of decision making – Unless the offence is serious; the offender contributed to the delay; the offence only recently came to light; or the complexity of the offence has contributed to long investigation.
GENERAL FACTORS FOR TRAFFIC OFFENCES
- Serious injury caused to public or significant damage caused
- Multiple offenders involved in similar offences at same time/location
- Potential risk to public or resultant danger
- Genuine oversight, technicality of the offence or emergency circumstances
- No danger caused to public
- Lack of knowledge
ABDUCTION
Abduction of a girl under 16 yrs
Kidnapping
False Imprisonment
ANIMALS (Domestic)
Animal Welfare Act 2006. Offences causing or likely to cause distress.
- Failing to heed advice
Animal Welfare Act 2006 Offences of cruelty or fighting
Dogs worrying livestock
- Level of killing/injuries
- No apparent injury
- Dog destroyed
Dangerous Dog (Order to be kept under control or destroyed)
- Cautioning not an option
- Cautioning not an option
Abandoning, or allowing to stray a fighting dog) Sec. 1.2e Dangerous Dogs Act 1991)
- Dog destroyed
Possession without exemption of a Pit Bull Terrier, Japanese Tosa or other Designated Fighting Dog (Sec1.3 Dangerous Dogs Act 1991)
- Dog destroyed
Owner or Person in Charge allowing dog to be dangerously out of control in a Public Place injuring any person (Sec. 3.1 Dangerous Dogs Act 1991)
- Serious injury
- No effort to control
- Minor injury
- Dog destroyed
- Beyond physical limitation of owner or person in charge
- First time person in charge
Owner or Person in Charge allowing dog to be dangerously out of control in a Public Place no injury being caused (Sec. 3.1 Dangerous Dogs Act 1991)
- Person placed in fear
- Intent/Disregard
- No injury/fear
- Dog destroyed
- Circumstances beyond the control of the offender
Owner or Person in Charge allowing dog to enter a Non-Public Place injuring any person (Sec. 3.3 Dangerous Dogs Act 1991)
- Serious injury
- Minor injury
- Dog destroyed
ASSAULTS
Threats to kill (S.16 OAP Act 1861)
- Calculated
- Threat made in heat of the moment
Poison - Administer/cause to be Administered noxious substance with intent to injure, etc.
Corrosive Fluid etc. - Throw with Intent to Maim etc.
GBH/Wounding with intent (S.18 OAP Act 1861)
GBH/Wounding (Sec. 20 OAP Act 1861)
ABH (S. 47 OAP Act 1861)
- Weapon Used
- More than one blow Attacked while victim vulnerable or defenceless e.g. 'on floor’
- Unprovoked attack
- Nature of the injury (especially where serious /disfiguring injury)
- Premeditated
- Domestic Violence
- Group action
- Impulsive action
- Provocation
- Minor injury
Assault on Police(Section 51 Police Act 1996)
Use the following link to the CPS guidance and scroll down for the link to the 2025 “Memorandum of Understanding on Offences against Emergency Workers”: https://www.cps.gov.uk/legal-guidance/assaults-emergency-workers-offences-act-2018
- Sustained assault
- Attempt to prevent arrest of another
- Premeditation
- Any injuries caused
- Group action
Common Assault(Section 39 Criminal Justice Act 1988)
- Deliberate aggression without provocation
- Vulnerable victim
- Weapon used
- Premeditation
- Domestic violence
- Group action
- Trivial nature of action
- Impulsive action
- Injury very minor
BIGAMY
Bigamy
- Clear deception where other party has suffered loss or severe emotional injury
- Spouse has been missing for a significant period but under 7 years
BURGLARY
Burglary with Intent to inflict GBH
Trespass with intent to commit a Sexual Offence(Sexual Offences Act 2003 update)
Aggravated Burglary
- Defer Decision to CPS
Burglary Dwelling - with use (or threat) of force against victim
Burglary Dwelling
- Deliberate targeting of victim/ vulnerable victim
- Excessive trauma experienced by victim
- Night time occupier present
- Use or threat of force against victim
- Professional operation Soiling / ransacking / vandalism of premises
- Pre-meditated or professionally planned
- Group offence ‘Ram-raiding’ or tools carried for offence High economic or sentimental value of property stolen/damaged
- Vacant premises
- Low value
- Coercion from others in group or reluctant offender
- Committed on impulse
- Genuine regret or remorse
- Property recovered and returned to owner
Burglary Non-Dwelling
- Deliberate targeting of victim/ vulnerable victim
- Excessive trauma experienced by victim
- Night time occupier present
- Use or threat of force against victim
- Professional operation Soiling / ransacking / vandalism of premises
- Pre-meditated or professionally planned
- Group offence ‘Ram-raiding’ or tools carried for offence High economic or sentimental value of property stolen/damaged
- Vacant premises
- Low value
- Coercion from others in group or reluctant offender
- Committed on impulse
- Genuine regret or remorse
- Property recovered and returned to owner
Burglary with Intent to Steal/Criminal Damage
- Deliberate targeting of victim/ vulnerable victim
- Excessive trauma experienced by victim
- Night time occupier present
- Use or threat of force against victim
- Professional operation Soiling / ransacking / vandalism of premises
- Pre-meditated or professionally planned
- Group offence ‘Ram-raiding’ or tools carried for offence High economic or sentimental value of property stolen/damaged
- Vacant premises
- Low value
- Coercion from others in group or reluctant offender
- Committed on impulse
- Genuine regret or remorse
- Property recovered and returned to owner
CRIMINAL DAMAGE
Criminal damage Criminal Damage valued at £300 (Home Office) £500 (max)
- Damage deliberate rather than reckless
- Potential of greater danger
- Group offence
- Damage £300+ approx.
- Damage £100 or less
Arson - life not endangered
- Damage deliberate
- Potential of greater danger
- Group offence
- Damage £300+ approx.
- Damage £100 or less
Criminal Damage (including arson) with intent to Endanger Life or Reckless as to whether Life is Endangered
Threat to destroy property of another
- Intent to cause fear
- Potential value of damage £300+ approx.
- Potential value of damage £1000 or less
Possession of Articles with Intent to Commit Criminal Damage
- Evidence of intent to commit serious criminal damage
- Potential value of damage £200+ (approx.)
- Potential value of damage £50 or less
CROSSBOWS
Purchase/Hire of Crossbow or Part by Person Under 17 (sec.2 Crossbows Act 1987)
Possession of Crossbow or Part by Person Under 17 (sec.3 Crossbows Act 1987)
CRUELTY
Cruelty/Ill Treatment to a child in a manner likely to cause unnecessary suffering or injury
DEATHS
Murder/ Manslaughter
Infanticide
Child Destruction
Suicide/Attempted Suicide-aid/ abet/counsel
DRUGS (FOR POSSESSION OF CANNABIS REFER TO ACPO GUIDANCE)
CLASS 'A' DRUG Supply/Possession with intent to supply
CLASS 'B' OR 'C' DRUG Supply/possession with intent to supply
- Group of people pooling resources to buy a supply of drugs to share between them.
- No profit made
CLASS 'A' DRUG Possession
- In prison establishment
- Large quantity
- Small quantities consistent with personal use
CLASS 'B' OR 'C' DRUG Possession
- In prison establishment
- Large quantity
- Small quantities consistent with personal use
CLASS 'A' DRUG Production
- Commercial cultivation
- Large quantity
- Small quantities consistent with personal use
CLASS 'B' OR 'C' DRUG Production/ Cultivation
- Small quantities consistent with personal use
Permit use of premises for smoking Cannabis or Cannabis Resin
- On commercial basis
- Evidence of widespread use
- Vulnerable offender
DRUNKENNESS
Drunk and Disorderly
- Risk of escalation
- Busy public place
- Offensive language or behaviour
- Threatening
- Only witnessed by a police officer
- Little inconvenience to the public
- Non-threatening
Drunk and incapable
Drinking in a Designated Area Section 12 Criminal Justice & Police Act 2001
Drunk on a highway or public place in charge of a child under 7 years
- Child of particularly tender years
- Child at risk
- More than one child
- Minimal risk to child
EXPLOSIVES
Explosive substances offences (most)
- Always refer to the CPS
Throwing firework Section 80 Explosives Act 1875
FALSE MESSAGES
Bomb Hoax (Section 51 Criminal Law Act 1977)
- ‘Copy –cat’ scenario
- Existing climate of fear
- Caused dangerous or large scale evacuation i.e. hospital, large sporting event
- Serious financial loss
- Obvious to recipient that a hoax
Sending Malicious Communication(S.1 Malicious Communication Act 1988)
- Persistency
- Obvious to recipient that a hoax
False Alarms to Emergency Services (Fire & Rescue Services Act 2004)
- Persistency
- Obvious to recipient that a hoax
Other False Emergency Calls (S.127 Communications Act 2003)
- Persistency
- Obvious to recipient that a hoax
Improper use of Telecom Systems (S.127 Communications Act 2003)
- Persistency
- Sexual and/or sadistic in nature.
- Consider charge if necessary to protect victim with restraining order
- Obvious to recipient that a hoax
FIREARMS
Use firearm to resist arrest
Possession of firearm with intent to endanger life/Injure Property (S.16 Firearms Act 1968)
Possession of firearm whilst committing offence or with intent to commit offence (S.17 & 18 Firearms Act 1968)
Carrying loaded firearm in public place (S.19 Firearms Act 1968)
- Type of weapon
- Discharge of weapon
Trespass in building with loaded Firearm (S.20 Firearms Act 1968)
- Type of weapon
- Discharge of weapon
Possession of firearm within set period of release (S.21 Firearms Act 1968)
- Type of weapon
- Discharge of weapon
Person under 17 purchasing firearm or ammunition (S.22 Firearms Act 1968)
- Type of weapon
Person under 17 having air weapon in public (S.22 Firearms Act 1968)
- Impact on the public
- Aware it was an offence
- Evidence of firing
Supply (includes sale) firearm or ammunition to person under 17 (S.24 Firearms Act 1968)
- Supply by firearms dealer
Possession of firearm/shotgun without certificate(S.1.1 & 2.1 Firearms Act 1968) a) No certificate ever held b) Following non-renewal
- Any form of usage
- Possession in public
- Type/construction of weapons (e.g. prohibited)
- History of lethargic renewal
- Deliberate avoidance of renewal procedure
Making false statement to procure grant, renewal, or variation of firearm/shotgun certificate (S.26.5 & 29.3 Firearms Act 1968)
- Previous conviction(s) omitted which would affect decision to grant, renew or vary
- Deliberate supply of false information
Firearm - failure to comply with condition of certificate in relation to security of weapons (S.1.2 & 2.2 Firearms Act 1968)
- Degree of carelessness/ insecurity
- Previous history of insecurity
- Certificate held for period of time - therefore knew of the requirement
Using a False Document (S.3 Forgery & Counterfeiting Act 1981)
- Nature of document and potential consequences
- Organised team
- Sophistication
- Poverty/personal need
- Coercion from others
Possessing a False Document with Intent (S.5 Forgery & Counterfeiting Act 1981)
- Nature of document and potential consequences
- Organised team
- Sophistication
- Poverty/personal need
- Coercion from others
Forgery of Documents etc. (Road Traffic Act 1988)
- Nature of document and potential consequences
- Organised team
- Sophistication
- Poverty/personal need
- Coercion from others
HARBOURING
Harbouring/Assist-ing escaped prisoners
HARASSMENT
Stalking
INTERFERENCE WITH THE COURSE OF JUSTICE
Conspiracy/Attempt to Pervert the Course of Justice
Perjury
Bail Personation
Escape from Lawful Custody
Prison - Escape/aid/assist
Breach of ASBO
LICENSING
Sale outside permitted hours
- Over a long period or
- Accumulation of periods
- Sold in large quantities
- Many customers
- Previous offences of similar nature
- Short period
- Little sold
- Isolated incident
- Few customers (less than 6)
Licensee or servant knowingly sell or allow person under 18 years to buy or consume intoxicating liquor in a bar
- Large number of under age drinkers on premises
- Recurring offence
- Low number on premises
- Isolated incident
- Genuine belief person over 18 years
Person under 18 years buy/attempt to buy
- Large number of under age drinkers on premises
- Low number on premises
- Isolated incident
Other person buy/attempt to buy for under 18 year old intoxicating liquor
- Recurring offence
- Genuine belief person over 18 years
Selling to a drunken person
- Frequent occurrence
- Isolated incident
Person enters licensed premises in breach of court exclusion order
MISCELLANEOUS
Breach of ASBO
Throwing stones at a trainSection 56 British Transport Commission Act 1949
Trespass on a RailwaySec 50 British Transport Commission Act 1949
Most Non-Recordable Offences
Breach of By-Laws
- Not a local resident
OBSTRUCTION
Obstruct Police (S.51 Police Act 1964)
Wilful Obstruction of Highway
- Close to traffic hazard e.g. School
- Large scale disruption
- Brief period only
- No considerable problems caused to other road users and/or pedestrians
OFFENSIVE WEAPONS
Possession of Offensive Weapon
- Method of use
- Concern caused to member(s) of public
- Degree of danger
Possession of Sharp Pointed Blade
- Method of use
- Concern caused to member(s) of public
- Genuine oversight in retaining blade after a lawful possession
Import prohibited weapons / ammunition with intent to evade a prohibition / restriction
- Large scale
- Nature of weapon
- Significant financial gain
PUBLIC ORDER
Riot (Section 1)
Violent Disorder (Section 2)
- Planned action
- Premeditated action
- Use of weapons
- People put in fear
- Damage caused
- Busy public place
- Large group
Affray (Section 3)
- Use of weapons
- People put in fear
- Damage caused
- Busy public place
- Group action
Threatening, abusive or insulting words or behaviour intended to cause fear of violence or to provoke violence (Section 4)
- Use of weapons
- Group action
- People put in fear
- Risk of escalation
- Busy public place
- No risk of escalation
Intentionally causing harassment, alarm or distress through threatening abusive or insulting words or behaviour or display (Section 4A)
- Racial overtones
- Risk of escalation
- Group action
- No risk of escalation
Threatening, abusive or insulting words or behaviour likely to cause harassment, alarm or distress (Section 5)
- Risk of escalation
- Group action
- Isolated incident
- No risk of escalation
Breach of ASBO
Incitement to cause racial hatred
- Use/Display of weapons
- Premeditated group action
- Extent to which person put in fear Risk of escalation
- Busy public place
- Group action
- Vulnerable victim(s)
- Single offender
- Heat of the moment
ROAD TRAFFIC
Causing death by dangerous driving (Section 1 Road Traffic Act 1988)
Causing death by careless driving under the influence of drink or drugs(Section 3 Road Traffic Act 1988)
Driving Whilst Disqualified
Excess Alcohol/ Driving when unfit through Drink/Drugs
Refusing to provide specimen of breath/blood/urine at police station
Drunk in Charge
Dangerous Driving (Section 2 Road Traffic Act 1988)
- Alcohol/drugs a factor
- Racing/ Competitive driving
- Grossly excessive speed
- Disregard for passenger warnings
- Persistent bad driving over a long period/ distance
- Serious Risk
- Avoiding detection or apprehension
- Continuing for only a short period
- Contributed to by action another
Failing to Stop After Accident/ Failure to Report Accident
- Blatant disregard of need
- Serious injury & failure to remain at scene
- Serious injury and/ or serious damage
- Evidence of drinking
- No intent to evade liability for the offence
- Genuine belief that relevant person aware
- Negligible damage
Careless driving (Section 3 Road Traffic Act 1988)
- Major error of judgement
- Excessive speed
- Driving with disregard for road safety taking account of road, whether and/or traffic conditions
- Re-Test may be appropriate- Sec.36 Road Traffic Offenders Act 1988
- Disability -s.22 RTOA 1988
- Deliberate act of selfishness, impatience or aggressiveness causing inconvenience
- Minor error of judgement
- Defect in road surface/signing, etc.
- Momentary lapse
- Adverse weather conditions
- Both (or more) drivers mat have been at fault
Inconsiderate Driving (Section 3 Road Traffic Act 1988)
- Major error of judgement
- Excessive speed
- Driving with disregard for road safety taking account of road, whether and/or traffic conditions
- Re-Test may be appropriate- Sec.36 Road Traffic Offenders Act 1988
- Disability -s.22 RTOA 1988
- Deliberate act of selfishness, impatience or aggressiveness causing inconvenience
- Minor error of judgement
- Defect in road surface/signing, etc.
- Momentary lapse
- Adverse weather conditions
- Both (or more) drivers mat have been at fault
a) Vehicle left in dangerous position
- Potential or actual danger intended
- Danger of serious injury to other road users
b) Tampering with vehicle (S.25 Road Traffic Act 1988)
- Potential or actual danger intended
- Danger of serious injury to other road users
c) Causing danger to other road users (S.22a Road Traffic Act 1988)
- Potential or actual danger intended
- Danger of serious injury to other road users
Driving after false declaration as to physical fitness/failing to notify disability and refusal or revocation of licence (Sections 92-94 Road Traffic Act 1988)
- Voluntary surrender of licence
Failure to provide specimen for roadside test
Speeding (above fixed penalty speed)
Wanton and Furious Driving/Riding
ROAD TRAFFIC DOCUMENTS
Driving other than in accordance with driving licence i.e. no 'L' plates
- Blatant disregard of need
'L' driver unaccompanied
- Blatant disregard of need
'L' driver carrying passengers
- Blatant disregard of need
No driving licence
- Blatant disregard of need
No insurance
- Deliberate offence
- Offence involving TWOC or other offence giving rise to danger
- Genuine mistake/technicality
- Duty to provide insurance resting with another e.g. parent, company, hirer, etc.
No test certificate
- Blatant disregard of need
- Genuine oversight
Fraudulent Use of Excise License
- Both vehicle owned by offender
Failure to notify change of ownership
- Blatant disregard of need
- Genuine oversight
Construction and use offences
- Blatant disregard of need
- Seriousness of defect(s)
- Genuine oversight
- Minor defect(s)
Drive vehicle subject to Prohibition Notice (Sec 71(1) Road Traffic Act 1988)
Motorway Offences
- Blatant disregard of regulations
- Serious risk to offender or other road users
- Genuine mistake
SEXUAL OFFENCES
Rape (Sec. 1)
Assault by Penetration (Sec. 2)
Sexual Assault(Sec. 3)
- Force used
- Elderly/younger victim
- Group action
Causing Person to Engage in Sexual Activity without Consent (Sec. 4) With Penetration
Causing Person to Engage in Sexual Activity without Consent (Sec. 4) Without Penetration
Rape of Child Under 13 (Sec. 5)
Assault of Child Under 13 by Penetration (Sec. 6)
Sexual Assault of Child Under 13(Sec. 7)
- Facilitated by drugs/ alcohol
- Force used
- Group action
- Offender and victim of similar age and no element of coercion or corruption present
Causing/Inciting Child Under 13 to Engage in Sexual Activity without Consent (Sec. 8)
Sexual Activity with Child (Sec. 9)
- Facilitated by drugs/ alcohol
- Force used
- Group action
- Offender and victim of similar age and no element of coercion or corruption present
Causing/Inciting Child to Engage in Sexual Activity (Sec. 10)
Engaging in Sexual Activity in Presence of Child (Sec. 11)
- Facilitated by drugs/ alcohol
- Force used
- Group action
- Offender and victim of similar age and no element of coercion or corruption present
Causing Child to Watch Sexual Act (Sec. 12)
- Facilitated by drugs/ alcohol
- Force used
- Group action
- Offender and victim of similar age and no element of coercion or corruption present
Sexual Activity with Child Family Member (Sec. 25)
- Victim did not wholly consent
- Element of coercion
- Victim Under 13
- Offender & victim are similar in age
- Both parties over age of consent and no element of coercion/seduction
Inciting Child Family Member to Engage in Sexual Activity (Sec. 26)
- Victim did not wholly consent
- Element of coercion
- Victim Under 13
- Offender & victim are similar in age
- Both parties over age of consent and no element of coercion/seduction
Sex with Adult Relative with Penetration and with or without Consent (Sec. 64 & 65)
Sexual Activity with Person with Mental Disorder (Sec. 30)
- Facilitated by drugs/ alcohol
- Force used
- Group action
- Both parties over age of consent and no element of coercion/seduction
- Offender has mental disorder
Causing/Inciting Person with Mental Disorder to Engage in Sexual Activity without Consent (Sec. 31)
- Facilitated by drugs/ alcohol
- Force used
- Group action
- Both parties over age of consent and no element of coercion/seduction
- Offender has mental disorder
Engaging in Sexual Activity in Presence of Person with Mental Disorder (Sec. 32)
- Facilitated by drugs/ alcohol
- Force used
- Group action
- Offender has mental disorder
Causing Person with Mental Disorder to Watch Sexual Act (Sec. 33)
- Facilitated by drugs/ alcohol
- Force used
- Group action
- Offender has mental disorder
Paying for Sexual Services of Child (sec. 47) with Penetration
Causing/Inciting Child Prostitution/ Pornography (Sec. 48)
- Victim under 13
Controlling Child Involved in Prostitution/Pornography (Sec. 49)
- Victim under 13
Arranging/Facilitation Child Prostitution/ Pornography (Sec. 50)
- Victim under 13
Administering Substance with Intent to Commit Sexual Offence (Sec. 61)
Commit Offence with Intent to Commit Sexual Offence (Sec. 62)
Trespass with Intent to Commit Sexual Offence (Sec. 63)
Exposure (Sec. 66)
- Victim put in fear
- Repeat performances
Voyeurism (Sec. 67)
- Victim distressed
- Victim observed in person
- Repeat performances
- Single event
Sexual Activity in Public Lavatory (Sec. 71)
- Genuine chance of public witnessing the offence
- Youth victim
- Consenting victim and over the age of legal consent
Common prostitute loitering for prostitution
Kerb crawling
- Affects residential areas
Possession of indecent photograph or image of a child S 160 Criminal Justice Act 1988
- Infant images
- Images of child under 13
- High number of level 3,4 or 5 images
- Images of a child known to offender
- Low level of images and just of Level 1 or 2
- Images are of older child and considered to be in the same peer group as offender
Take / Permit to be taken / Show / Make / Possess with a view to distribution / Publish an advert / Cause an advert to be Published of Indecent Photographs / Pseudo Photograph of a Child S1 Protection of Children Act 1978
- Infant images
- Images of child under 13
- High number of level 3,4 or 5 images
- Images of a child known to offender
- A large financial gain / commercial operation
- Low level of images and just of Level 1 or 2
- Images are of older child and considered to be in the same peer group as offender
SPORTING EVENTS
Intoxicating liquor in possession on specified vehicle (Sections 1.3 & 1A.3)
- Group involvement
- Large quantity
- Small quantity
Drunk in a specified vehicle (Sections 1.4 & 1A.4)
- Group involvement
- Risk of escalation
- Threatening
- Non-threatening
Intoxicating liquor/article in possession whilst entering or inside (viewing area) sports ground (Section 2.1) 2
- Group involvement
- Risk of escalation
Entering or being in a sports ground whilst drunk (Section 2.2)
- Group involvement
- Risk of escalation
- Threatening
- Non-threatening
THEFT
Robbery/Assault with Intent to Rob
- Always refer to the CPS
Theft
- Planned
- Sophistication
- Organised team
- Value of £200+ (approx.)
- Unrecovered property of considerable value
- Adult involving children
- Significant related damage
- Theft for reasons of poverty/personal need
- Coercion from others in group in reluctant offender
Going equipped to steal
Possession of articles for use in frauds (Section 6 of the Fraud Act 2006)
- Sophisticated
- Poor quality
Making/supplying articles for use in frauds(Section 7 of the Fraud Act 2006)
- Sophisticated
- Poor quality
Handling stolen property
- Property stolen to order
- Professional receiver
- Youth coercing children
- Property of high value
- Received under pressure from another
- Very low value
Abstracting electricity
- Special equipment
- High usage
- Prolonged period
- Commercial gain such as cannabis farms
- Poverty/ personal need
- Coercion by others
Fraud by false representation Section 1 and 2 Fraud Act 2006
- Sophistication
- Two or more involved
- Committed over lengthy period
- Unrecovered property of considerable value
- Value £200+approx
- Poverty/ personal need
- Coercion from others in group in reluctant offender
- Value £100 or less
Fraud by failing to disclose information (Sections 1 and 3 of the Fraud Act 2006)
- Sophistication
- Organised team
- Unrecovered property of considerable value
- Value £200+ (approx.)
- Poverty/ personal need
- Coercion from others in group in reluctant offender
- Value £100 or less
Fraud by abuse of position (Sections 1 and 4 of the Fraud Act 20006)
- Sophistication
- Organised team
- Unrecovered property of considerable value
- Value £200+ (approx.)
- Poverty/ personal need
- Coercion from others in group in reluctant offender
- Value £100 or less
False Accounting
- Sophistication
- Value £200+ (approx.)
- Value £100 or less
Blackmail
Taking vehicle without consent
- Premeditated
- Group action
- Organised team
- Commercial basis (stole to order)
- Causes damage to vehicle or other property
- Excessive speed to avoid apprehension
- Evidence of drugs/alcohol
- Taking from family member
- The taking is a technical offence
- Employee using outside working hours
- Keys left in vehicle
Allowing self to be carried in vehicle taken without owner's consent
- Premeditated
- Group action
- Organised team
- Commercial basis (stole to order)
- Causes damage to vehicle or other property
- Excessive speed to avoid apprehension
- Evidence of drugs/alcohol
- Misunderstanding with owner
- Technical offence
- Keys left in vehicle
- Employee using outside working hours
Aggravated Vehicle Taking where owing to the Driving of the Vehicle, an Accident occurred causing injury to any person
- The taking is a technical offence
- Injured is member of drivers family
Aggravated vehicle taking where: a) Damage to any Property other than the vehicle b) Damage was caused to the vehicle (c) The vehicle was driven Dangerously on a road or other Public Place (Section 1 Aggravated Vehicle Taking Act 1992
- Competitive driving or racing
- Drives furiously/recklessly to avoid apprehension/ detection
- Excessive speed
- Evidence of drugs/ alcohol
- Disregards warnings from passengers or others
- Premeditated
- Group action
- Evidence of alcohol or drugs
- Serious risk
- Minor damage
- The taking is a technical offence
- Damage to own family property
Tampering with Motor Vehicle (S.25 RTA 1988)
- Potential or actual danger intended
Interference with Vehicle (S.9 Criminal Attempts Act 1981)
- Damage to Vehicle
Making Off Without Payment (Section 3 Theft Act 1978)
- Deliberate plan
- Two or more involved
- Large amount involved
- Small amount involved
WASTING POLICE TIME
Wasting Police Time
- Detention of innocent person
- Substantial time wasted
- Early retraction and remorse
- Innocent prank
WILDLIFE (Animals and Plants)
Control of Trade in Endangered Species Regulations 1997 (COTES)
- Offence relates to a species subject of focus within the wildlife crime priority.
- Offence results in or is intended to result in financial gain.
- Professional involvement in trade, e.g. pet shop, online retailer, zoo, animal park etc
- Organised or premeditated offence.
- Offence relates to a species subject of focus within the wildlife crime priority.
- Offence results in or is intended to result in financial gain.
- Professional involvement in trade, e.g. pet shop, online retailer, zoo, animal park etc
- Organised or premeditated offence.
Customs and Excise Management Act 1979
- Conservation impact of offence.
- Offence relates to a prohibited or restricted species and may be subject of focus within the wildlife crime priority.
- Offence results in or is intended to result in financial gain.
- Professional involvement in trade, e.g. pet shop, online retailer, Commercial retailer, zoo, animal park etc
- Organised or premeditated offence.
- Administrative offence rather than deliberate
Wildlife and Countryside Act 1981. Conservation Habitats and Species Regulations 2010 Protection of Badgers Act 1992 Conservation of Seals Act 1970
- Offence relates to a wildlife crime priority.
- Conservation impact of the offence.
- Offence results in or is intended to result in financial gain.
- Offence involves cruelty.
- Planned or premeditated offence.
- Offences committed by mistake or misunderstanding.
- Little or no conservation impact.
- Licences etc remain valid despite conditions having been breached.
Wildlife and Countryside 1981 Conservation Habitats and Species Regulations 2010
- Conservation impact of the offence.
- Offence results in or is intended to result in financial gain.
- Offence involves cruelty.
- Planned or premeditated offence.
- Offences committed by mistake or misunderstanding.
- Little or no conservation impact.
Poaching Game Acts Deer Act 1981
- Offence relates to species subject of focus within the wildlife crime priority (fish, deer, brown hare)
- Offence results in or is intended to result in financial gain.
- Offence involves cruelty.
- Planned or premeditated offence.
- Use of threats or violence.
- Prevalence of offence/community impact.
- Offences committed by mistake or misunderstanding.
- Small number of non priority species taken for personal consumption.
Hunting Act 2004
Wild mammals (Protection) Act 1996
Food and Environmental Protection Act 1985 Control of Pesticides Regulations 1986
- Planned or premeditated offence
- Risk to human health and safety
- Links to wildlife crime priority.
- Prevalence of offences.
- Unused stocks of pesticides previously used lawfully.
- Oversight/ mistake/genuine ignorance.
15.1 The presumptions applicable to the final gravity score reached, when all the relevant factors have been applied to the circumstances of a particular offence, are listed in the table below. This must be used in conjunction with the legislation in relation to the offender’s qualification for caution, conditional caution or charge.
15.2 Officers should remember that it will sometimes be necessary to consult agencies or departments such as the Crown Prosecution Service, Sex Crimes Department, Firearms Department, Licensing Officers, etc., before a final decision is made even if all the evidence is available.
15.3 This table relates to disposal/outcome decisions made by the custody officer for the offences shown and relates to action that should be taken once the final score is deduced.
*Note that where a conditional caution is being considered for a Foreign National Offenders the DPP Guidance should be referred to in terms of the seriousness of the offence for which a Conditional Caution may be offered.
| Final Score | Action |
|---|---|
| 4 | Always charge (or conditional caution – may need CPS decision if IO and exceptional circumstances). |
| 3 | Normally charge but a 'simple' caution (or conditional caution – may need CPS decision if IO and exceptional circumstances) may be appropriate if first offence. PND may be appropriate. |
| 2 | Normally 'simple' caution for a first offence but a charge (or conditional caution – may need CPS decision if IO and exceptional circumstances) may be appropriate if previous convictions or appropriate to circumstances. PND may be appropriate. |
| 1 | Always the minimum response applicable to the individual offender, i.e. NFA, 'simple' caution, PND, Community Resolution (or, exceptionally, charge). |
- Conviction is likely to result in significant sentence.
- Weapon used or violence threatened during commission of offence.
- Offence against public servant (e.g. police, nurse, council employee, etc.).
- Offender abused a position of trust – e.g. banker, baby-sitter, shop assistant.
- Offender was ringleader/organiser.
- Evidence of premeditation.
- Offender was part of an organised team or offence was committed by a group.
- Victim was vulnerable, deliberately put in considerable fear or suffered personal attack, damage, disturbance, or domestic violence.
- Offence motivated by discrimination against victim's racial or ethnic origin, religious beliefs, gender, political views or sexual preference.
- There are grounds for believing the offence is likely to be repeated or continued – e.g. by a history of recurring conduct.
- Evidence of exploitation.
- The offence, though minor, is prevalent in the local area – as identified in the local crime audit, specified in the youth justice plan or specifically agreed with CPS to warrant more serious response.
- Conviction is likely to result in unusually small or nominal penalty.
- Prosecution is likely to have detrimental effect on victim's physical or mental health.
- Offender supplied information which reduced risk, loss or harm to others.
- Offender was influenced by others more criminally sophisticated.
- Genuine mistake or misunderstanding.
- Vulnerability of the offender.
- Provocation from victim or victim's group and offender reacted impulsively.
- The offence is minor and offender has put right harm or loss caused; has expressed regret; offered reparation or compensation.
- Offender is or was at time of offence suffering from significant mental or physical ill-health and offence is not likely to be repeated.
- The offence is so old that the relevance of any response is minimised, i.e. there has been a long delay between the offence occurring and the point of decision making – Unless the offence is serious; the offender contributed to the delay; the offence only recently came to light; or the complexity of the offence has contributed to long investigation.
- Serious injury caused to public or significant damage caused
- Multiple offenders involved in similar offences at same time/location
- Potential risk to public or resultant danger
- Genuine oversight, technicality of the offence or emergency circumstances
- No danger caused to public
- Lack of knowledge
